Written answer by Ministry of National Development on timeframe for coffee shop operators to replace sole halal food stall which ceased operations with another halal vendor

May 8, 2023

Question No: 2943

Question by: Assoc Prof Jamus Jerome Lim

To ask the Minister for National Development (a) whether the Ministry has considered (i) implementing a fixed timeframe within which coffeeshop operators are required to replace their sole halal food stall with another halal vendor once the original vendor ceases to operate and (ii) imposing stricter penalties against coffeeshop operators who fail to do so, beyond not renewing their leases in the future; and (b) if not, why not.

Answer:

Since 2005, HDB coffeeshop operators are required under their tenancy agreements to have at least one halal stall. Should the halal stall operator cease operation, the coffeeshop operator is required to find a replacement within the current tenancy period. It is in the interest of the operator to find a replacement as soon as possible, to minimise loss of revenue arising from the vacant stall.

2.       If the operator fails to find a replacement, HDB may decide not to renew the tenancy or as a last resort, terminate the tenancy. However, before taking such action, HDB will discuss and work with existing operators to resolve the issue, or to allow operators more time to adjust or find a replacement.

3.      Stricter penalties, as suggested by the Member’s question, might not be the best strategy for bringing about the desired outcome of halal food availability. MND and HDB are concerned about residents’ needs and have also been listening to the feedback of coffeeshop operators. Some have found it difficult to secure replacement stalls due to lower demand in certain areas or strong competition from other options nearby. Hence, we are prepared to consider alternative approaches. We will engage the industry for feedback and work with them to co-create solutions for maintaining good availability of halal cooked food in HDB coffeeshops.